Funny

We Could Have Had Benches, but the City Chose Hostile Architecture and a Press Release

Share
Facebook Pinterest X Reddit
Add us on Google

I sat on a bench last week that had clearly been designed by someone who hates sitting. It was tilted, it was cold, and it had a metal bar in the middle, like the bench itself was trying to break up with me. That is hostile architecture, and I love the name because it is the only honest thing about it. The city calls it a leaning rail or a comfort perch, and you have to admire the nerve. Have a look at what your tax dollars built so that nobody could rest.

Concrete spheres installed in a sidewalk alcove beside a brick building, wrapped in caution tape.

A ball pit nobody is allowed to enjoy.

Save
News post about downward tilting toilets designed to be uncomfortable after five minutes for productivity.

Thirteen degrees of managerial trust.

Save
Spiked window bars covered in deflated soccer balls that were punctured after landing there.

A memorial wall for recess.

Save
City poster on a utility pole reading see a tent, report a tent, with app instructions.

An app for everything except the actual problem.

Save
Hostile architecture example: long stone planter ledge fitted with a row of metal spike plates.

A perfectly good ledge, ruined on purpose.

Save
Close view of a metal spike plate bolted to a stone ledge beside shrubs.

A cheese grater for the public.

Save
Tweet arguing suburbs without sidewalks or bike lanes isolate children more than smartphones do.

The phone is the only thing in that neighborhood you can walk to.

Save
Slanted metal leaning stool on a wall under a sign inviting people to take a break.

Take a break, but make it a wall sit.

Save
Wooden bench in a redwood forest with a metal bar bolted across the middle of the seat.

Who was the forest worried about?

Save
Fold down bench seats padlocked shut against a wooden wall along a city sidewalk.

Seating by appointment only.

Save
Metal pipe studded with sharp spikes running along a building's stone window ledge.

Medieval, but with a maintenance budget.

Save
Curved metal bars installed along low window ledges of a stone building to block sitting.

Ribs for a ledge that never hurt anybody.

Save
Narrow sloped perch seats on a London Underground platform wall at Wood Lane station.

Technically a seat. Legally a suggestion.

Save
Bench made from two polished steel tubes in a sandy park, allowing only an awkward lean.

A bench as described to someone over the phone.

Save
Traveler asleep across airport seats, threading their body underneath the fixed armrests.

Human ingenuity, one. Armrests, zero.

Save
Paved courtyard between apartment blocks filled with rows of staggered green metal railings.

A maze with no cheese.

Save
Perforated metal bench at a transit stop with raised dividers splitting each seat.

Assigned seating for the bus you missed.

Save
Green park bench with an open gap in the middle marked for a wheelchair user.

Plot twist: this one is actually kind.

Save
Video game screenshot of a concrete street bench covered in metal studs at night.

Even the dystopian video game thought it was a bit much.

Save
Small round wooden disc seats mounted along a granite wall in a subway station.

Coasters for people.

Save
Rows of angled metal spikes lining a sloped concrete ledge outside an apartment building.

The ledge was already slanted. This is just spite.

Save

Hostile architecture

Read More

What gets me is the spikes. Somebody looked at a window ledge, a flat piece of stone doing nothing to anyone, and thought, that needs teeth. Everybody outside the planning office calls this anti homeless architecture, because that is who it is aimed at. But a spike cannot check your bank balance. It also gets the old man catching his breath, the kid tying a shoe, and me, a person who simply gets tired.

Then there are the uncomfortable benches, which are my favorite kind of lie. A bench has one job, and these have been carefully engineered not to do it. I leaned on one of those slanted perches for ten minutes once and slid off so slowly that nobody noticed, including me. They put an armrest in the middle of a seat in the woods, and I would love to know who the forest was worried about.

The part that turns urban design fails into something darker is the money. A tilted seat costs more than a flat one, and a locked bench costs more than an open one. So we are not saving anything. We are paying extra, on purpose, for a worse city, and then acting surprised that nobody hangs around downtown anymore. I pay my taxes, mostly on time, and I would like one flat bench back.

Here is the trick they are playing. You cannot design away a person, you can only design away the place where that person was sitting. So the person moves forty feet, the city gets to say the problem is solved, and the rest of us inherit a town where there is nowhere to wait for a friend. It is the most expensive way anyone has ever found to accomplish nothing.

And I think people share these photos because they feel it in their own legs. You do not need a degree to know when a place does not want you there. I have stood in a train station for forty minutes, holding two bags, staring at a row of little wooden discs on a wall and wondering what I did. A good city lets you sit down without asking why. That is really all a bench is: a public way of saying stay a minute, you are allowed to be here.

The ledge has teeth. The bench has rules. Sit anyway.

If you are now angry at a sidewalk, we can help with that. The urban hellscapes collection has plenty more places built by people who have never walked anywhere, and the design fails are a gentler kind of bad, more ugly than cruel. We also keep a deep pile of architecture fails and some truly baffling bathroom designs. Read them sitting down, on something flat. You have earned a chair.

Who needs to see this?

Send it to the friend who’ll laugh the hardest, or post it for everyone.

Posted by Thunder Dungeon Staff About the author

Thunder Dungeon Staff is the byline for galleries our team makes together, led by co-founders Roy R. and Phil M. We've been curating internet humor since 2012: finding the funniest memes, pictures and posts, crediting creators wherever we can, and adding our own take. Roy or Phil reviews every post before it goes live.

Want more of this in your Google results?

Pick us as a preferred source and our memes show up more in Google’s Top Stories.

Add us on Google
Up next
Up next The Nightcap: 25 Best Memes Today for Anyone Still Wearing Face Paint Read next