Every October I promise myself a cute costume, and every October I end up as something that makes a toddler hide behind a mailbox. So I have nothing but sympathy for creepy costumes made completely by accident. Nobody here wanted to scare anyone; they wanted to be a beloved cartoon, they had a glue gun and some yellow face paint, and then something went wrong in the dark. Walk slowly, keep your candy close, and meet the characters who came out of the craft drawer a little different.

Unacceptable.
Save
Bouncing is not what's happening here.
Save
Silly old bear has a mortgage now.
Save
Is mayonnaise a costume?
Save
Thing One is hiding. Thing Two is gone.
Save
She knows exactly how good this costume is.
Save
Sunlight is not this person's friend.
Save
Dobby is free. Dobby will not be leaving.
Save
Small clown. Big plans.
Save
Pika… pika… cough.
Save
I'm not lovin' it.
Save
Eat my shorts, then run.
Save
Mmm… nightmares.
Save
Confidence: unlimited.
Save
Big toe energy.
Save
Screen accurate, which is the problem.
Save
Get out of my porch.
Save
Hmmmmm.
Save
Do not shake hands.
Save
Table for two.
Save
The swamp had a glow up.
Save
Not a regular show.
Save
Perry is the only one who seems calm.
Save
The football head is doing too much.
Save
What's up, doc? Nothing good.
Save
Friendship is not magic here.
Save
Everyone is smiling. Nobody is happy.
Save
Bikini Bottom after the rent went up.
Save
Let's eat, she said, ominously.
Save
Night shift is short staffed.
SaveCreepy costumes
Read More
The bodysuit is where most halloween costume fails begin, because spandex hides nothing and forgives even less. A cartoon body was never meant to exist in three dimensions with knees. When someone zips into head to toe yellow and strikes a casual pose, the result is not a cute mascot, it is the mascot’s uncle on a smoke break. I once wore a full banana suit to a party and a child asked me if I was sick.
Then come the diy halloween costumes, which I respect deeply, the way you respect a bear. Duct tape and papier mache are wonderful materials for building something that looks like the character from forty feet away and like a hostage from four. The eyes are always the problem. Get the eyes slightly wrong and a beloved animated friend suddenly looks like they know where you sleep.
Group costumes multiply the effect, because one off model cartoon is a joke and five is a cult. A whole family of yellow faces lined up on a couch has the energy of a photo found in an abandoned house. These are cosplay fails only in the sense that they failed upward, straight into local folklore. I would not open the door for them, and I would absolutely ask for a picture.
The magic of an accidental monster is that nobody planned the horror. A scary costume is trying to scare you, and you can see it trying, like a dog doing a trick. These people were trying to be adorable, and the fear sneaked in on its own, through the eyeholes, like a draft. That accident is the purest form of Halloween there is.
There is something lovely about it, too. Every one of these started with somebody at a kitchen table, surrounded by glue and good intentions, absolutely certain they were about to make their friends smile. They did make us smile, just from behind a couch. I have been that person, holding a mask I made at two in the morning and slowly realizing it was looking back at me, so keep making them anyway.
The glue dried. The eyes moved. The neighbors moved.
If you still have the nerve, our cursed cosplay collection has plenty more characters who came out wrong, and the creepy vintage Halloween costumes prove our grandparents were somehow even scarier. For people who prefer their nightmares on a budget, the low cost cosplay archive is pure genius held together with tape. We also have costume ideas and spooky meme threads all month long. Lock the door. Then keep scrolling.

Who needs to see this?
Send it to the friend who’ll laugh the hardest, or post it for everyone.
